Louisiana Judge Tells Prediction Market Operators to Stop Event Contracts

A Louisiana state court has ordered Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase and several other prediction market operators to cease offering event contracts to local customers without a state gaming license. Louisiana Judge Orders Prediction Markets to Geofence State Users The temporary restraining…
A Louisiana state court has ordered Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase and several other prediction market operators to cease offering event contracts to local customers without a state gaming license. Louisiana Judge Orders Prediction Markets to Geofence State Users The temporary restraining order, dated November 12, is another escalation in the intensifying fight over whether prediction markets are subject to federal financial regulation or state gambling laws, as reported by NOLA.com. Tangipahoa Parish 21st Judicial District Court Judge Jeffrey Johnson approved the emergency request filed by Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill. The order prohibits the named companies from offering or facilitating contracts that are tied to sports, elections, entertainment, awards, and other uncertain events involving Louisiana residents. The ruling also obliges the operators to limit access to their services in the state. The companies must implement geofencing measures to prevent Louisiana customers from trading the covered contracts. Murrill’s office filed a civil lawsuit against 31 corporate entities representing 10 parent companies. The defendants include operators tied to Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini, ForecastEx, Novig, Underdog and ProphetX. The attorney general contends these products are gambling because customers are risking money on the outcome of future events. She says operators must get the appropriate state licenses before providing such services. Murrill is also looking to pursue civil penalties against the companies. She says labeling wagers as financial instruments does not exempt businesses from Louisiana’s gambling laws. However, the platforms dispute that reading. They argue that their event contracts are derivatives traded on exchanges regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Depending on its position, federal law gives the agency exclusive oversight and prevents states from enacting separate gambling requirements. Louisiana Dispute Adds to Growing Legal Pressure on Prediction Markets The legal fight exploded the same day the state court ruled. Kalshi has also filed an emergency motion in federal court seeking protection from Louisiana’s enforcement efforts. The company already sued Murrill and other state officials on October 23, claiming that Louisiana cannot enforce its gambling laws on its federally regulated operations. A separate federal challenge was launched by Polymarket US on October 27. The platforms’ arguments also run into headwinds elsewhere. Last month, the 6th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Ohio and Tennessee could apply their gambling laws to prediction market contracts. The decision was another in a string of conflicting court rulings across the country. Kalshi has also encountered resistance from Native American gaming interests. Tribal representatives say sports-related contracts compete with existing gambling businesses and undermine their gaming rights. Tribal entities have sued the company in California, New Mexico and Wisconsin. The Louisiana case is just the latest in a national regulatory battle. More than a dozen states have filed legal action against operators of prediction markets for their sports-related products. Judge Johnson scheduled a hearing on November 30 on Louisiana’s request for a preliminary injunction. That temporary restraining order is expected to last 10 days, unless the court extends it. The result may have important implications for prediction markets that want nationwide access. It also may help clarify how state gambling authorities and federal regulators divide oversight of these increasingly popular platforms.