GGNews
▾

Betting ban: secrecy of documents and Revenue Service calculations questioned

Por Cristina Possamai4 min de lecturaigamingbrazil.com ↗
Betting ban: secrecy of documents and Revenue Service calculations questioned

The Ministry of Finance placed under secrecy the preparatory documentation for the Provisional Measure (MP) that suspended the activities of online betting companies in Brazil. The text was signed by […] O post Betting ban: secrecy of documents and Revenue Service calculations questioned apareceu p…

The Ministry of Finance placed under secrecy the preparatory documentation for the Provisional Measure (MP) that suspended the activities of online betting companies in Brazil. The text was signed by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva (PT) on September 25. The ministry denied a request for access to the documents filed by Estadão, under the Access to Information Law (LAI). The provisional measure was issued less than two years after the federal government approved the regulation of sports betting and online gaming, which took effect on January 1, 2025. What was the argument for denying access to the MP documents The Ministry of Finance claimed that the documentation is of a legal advisory nature. As a result, the officials of the Attorney General’s Office for the National Treasury (PGFN) responsible for preparing the documents would be protected by attorney-client privilege. PGFN members are part of the Office of the Attorney General of the Union (AGU) and are subject to the prerogatives of public legal practice. However, the access restriction also covers documents that were not directly produced by PGFN. “This (functional) protection extends to the technical documents that supported the preparation of the legal opinions,” the Ministry of Finance stated in its official response. The ministry claimed that the MP on betting is provisional in nature because it still requires approval from Congress, even though the text has “immediate legal effects as of its publication.” According to Estadão, the denial represents a shift in the Ministry of Finance’s stance regarding the application of the LAI to similar requests. In May, the newspaper requested, also under the LAI, access to the preparatory documents for the so-called “MP das blusinhas,” related to the end of taxation on imported products worth up to $50. At the time, the ministry granted access, including to documents prepared by PGFN. When asked about the difference in treatment between the requests, the Ministry of Finance stated, through its press office, that “the analysis of access restrictions on legal opinions is carried out by PGFN on a case-by-case basis.” Federal Revenue Service technical note The Estadão report also highlighted one of the documents that supported the provisional measure. Namely, a technical note prepared by the Federal Revenue Service, produced on the same date the MP was issued. The opinion was cited in a case before the Federal Supreme Court (STF). According to the document, “the legislative change now proposed implies an estimated revenue reduction” of R$5.150 billion for 2027 and R$5.330 billion for 2028. The 2027 Annual Budget Bill (PLOA) projected revenue of R$5.2 billion from betting. Still according to Estadão, the projected amounts represent less than half of the revenue obtained by the federal government from the licensed sector in 2025. In the first year of the regulated market, betting companies paid R$9.9 billion in taxes. Between January and September 2026, the amount reached R$11.1 billion. The newspaper sent several inquiries to the Federal Revenue Service about the methodology used to calculate the estimates presented in the technical note, but did not receive detailed clarification. The agency only stated that the figures refer to projected revenue under the item called “legal allocations.” After further inquiries from Estadão, the Federal Revenue Service stated, on October 29, that betting companies “will continue to be subject to” the taxes not altered by the provisional measure “until the end of their operations in the country, a fact that has not yet occurred.” However, the text of the MP indicates that the companies’ licenses were revoked on October 26. Industry entities point to lack of transparency Speaking to Estadão, the National Association of Gaming and Lotteries (ANJL) stated that “the methodology and calculation records that led the Revenue Service to these conclusions are unknown,” and said it believes there was an “effort by the economic team to produce figures that would justify banning the betting market.” The association also questioned the lack of transparency in the process: “one must ask who benefits from this lack of transparency, which, in the end, has harmed millions of bettors who, since late September, have been completely exposed to the illegal market,” it said. Meanwhile, the Brazilian Institute of Responsible Gaming (IBJR) stressed the need to disclose the criteria used by the government: “Society needs to know how the government arrived at these figures and have access to the calculation records and the adjustments that will be made to the budget bill. A decision of this magnitude requires a complete, verifiable, and technically accurate accounting,” it concluded. O post Betting ban: secrecy of documents and Revenue Service calculations questioned apareceu primeiro em iGaming Brazil.

Compartir:XLinkedInTelegram