Will South Africa repeat Kenya’s messy gambling tax?

South Africa is proposing a national 20% GGR levy on online gambling providers, but Kenya tried a similar approach and messed up unceremoniously. For those familiar with gambling in Africa, Kenya will be a well-known case of tax policies almost ruining the licensed sector. In 2019, the Kenyan gover…
South Africa is proposing a national 20% GGR levy on online gambling providers, but Kenya tried a similar approach and messed up unceremoniously. For those familiar with gambling in Africa, Kenya will be a well-known case of tax policies almost ruining the licensed sector. In 2019, the Kenyan government introduced a 20% excise duty on betting stakes, which added to the already-existing 15% GGR tax on bookmakers. Then, in 2020 the excise duty was abolished following concerns about its impact on the regulated betting market. In 2021, the government once again considered introducing the same rate, only to instead implement a lower rate of 7.5%. In 2022, the country’s Treasury proposed to raise this back to 20%, bringing back more headaches for local gambling operators. The rate subsequently climbed to 12.5% and then 15% in the years that followed, only to be dropped back down to 5% in 2025. This tax limbo was one of the reasons why we saw an exodus of big brands leaving the market, such as Betin, Betsafe, and SportPesa, although the latter returned under a new operating structure. South Africa is now in a similar position, where an already overtaxed market is potentially facing a massive 20% tax add-on on its GGR. Operators are now urging the government to learn from what transpired in Kenya. Big brands caution against Kenya PTSD The South African National Treasury has put the tax up for public consultation, holding a stakeholder meeting that was attended by more than 160 people. Kenya was continuously mentioned throughout the hours of evidence as to why the SA government needs to reconsider. Speaking on behalf of Hollywoodbets, the second biggest operator there, Jerome Brink, Director at legal office CDH, said: “There’s another example from Kenya: tax caused capital flight, brand exits, and eventually the Kenyan government walked it back. So it’s not a case of may; it’s a case of it will happen, and I think that’s the critical issue. “A policy that increases the effective tax rate past 50% is not going to curb the problem. It’s not going to curb problem gambling. It’s going to simply offshore it. “It’s going to shrink the formal fiscus. You’re not going to get the revenue raising that the Treasury thinks it will. It’s going to jeopardise 1000s of local jobs, and it’s going to enrich unregulated syndicates. We urge the National Treasury to pause the proposed 20% tax.” Kenya was also in the thoughts of Ulrik Bengtsson, Chief Executive Officer of Sun International, which operates the local brand Sunbet Digital. “Kenya increased taxes to 20% of stakes,” he said. “The consequence of that was that some of the major operators actually left the market completely, eroding the tax base and leaving the market completely open for offshore operators. “Ultimately, the Kenyan government had to roll this back because the entire tax base was eroded. This is not something we talk about because we have nothing better to do. This is real. “It happens immediately, and again, it damages the local licensed industry and puts operators that want to be playing in through legal means at a disadvantage.” South Africa’s onion tax regime South Africa’s licensed operators, both online and land-based, are already subject to several layers of taxes. This includes the Provincial Gambling Tax, which ranges between 6% and 9% of their GGR, a flat 15% VAT on bets (payouts deducted), a corporate income tax on their net profits, and annual contributions to the South African Responsible Gambling Foundation. Sean Coleman, Chief Executive Officer of the South African Bookmakers Association (SABA), visualised just how high the tax rate for operators will be if the 20% GGR levy gets adopted. For illustrative purposes, he showed G as the VAT-inclusive GGR, P as the provincial rate, and V as the net VAT paid (divided by G). The current tax equation that operators are subject to is G = P + V. The proposed tax would change this to G = P + V + 20%. If P is an average of 6.5% and V is 12%, the licensed operator is currently taxed 18.5% of its GGR. With the new levy in place, online brands are looking at a tax rate of 38.5%. And while true that the 20% increase would only affect digital operations, Coleman reminded that the online and land-based offers are often tightly connected financially. This will ring some bells for our audience back in the UK, where last year’s increase in Remote Gaming Duty from 21% to 40% inadvertently led to many operators with both digital and retail presence cutting down their physical shops as a necessary cost mitigation measure. Flutter ponders closure of 100 Paddy Power shops due to higher taxes and “economic uncertainty” Coleman continued: “In many instances, the financial performance of the online operation helps sustain the retail component, particularly where retail margins are under pressure from rising operating costs and changing consumer behaviour. “An additional 20% tax on the online gross gaming revenue, therefore, does not affect online operations alone. It reduces the resources potentially available to supply retail premises, employees, and shared operating costs. “For some operators, this could make marginal retail outlets unviable, leading to closure and the loss of formal jobs.” Government makes its case The Treasury remained adamant throughout that the tax is necessary to address a surge in online gambling, and what the government perceives as an increase in harmful behaviour as a result. Ntombi Mabena, Senior Economist at the South Africa National Treasury, told stakeholders that the increase in access and visibility of online gambling has warranted a response from a regulatory standpoint, which will aim to tackle the social costs that online gambling incurs. According to Mabena, the additional 20% nation-wide tax on GGR will raise more than R10bn in extra state revenue at the current GGR basis, part of which could then be put into combating gambling harm. “Taxation raises the cost of gambling to curb excessive consumption, while funding measures that address the harm it causes”, Mabena’s presentation read. Transferring the cost to the end consumer, however, is not guaranteed to stop demand. Rather, it could potentially lead to players migrating offshore and worsening channelisation rates, which in turn would bring less income for the Treasury – essentially creating the paradox where more taxes generate less tax revenue. We’ve already seen this happen in the Netherlands. The other potential scenario, of course, is a repeat of what happened in Kenya not so long ago. But if the Netherlands is only one example, Bengtsson’s long international career has seen similar results replicated globally. “I’ve worked in almost all gambling markets in the world over the last 20 years, and I’ve never seen taxes reduce problem gambling,” he said. “There is no evidence of that. Higher taxes are highly damaging for the local industry, and put it and employed people here at a disadvantage to those who provide no protection, no taxes to the local economy.” The National Treasury has until the February 2027 Budget Speech to announce its final tax proposal. Until then, it has time to consider the warnings, reflect on the recommendations, and engage in dialogue.Therefore, South Africa’s government has all the examples, both good and bad, ahead of it to draw from. Which will it choose to see and which to ignore will become clear over the next 12 months.