GGNews
▾

Brazil: Congress urged to force betting refunds

Von Ted Menmuir4 Min. LesezeitSBC News ↗
Brazil: Congress urged to force betting refunds

A proposal by deputy Ricardo Abrão to make Bets operators reimburse customer losses has drawn instant criticism from Brazilian legal experts. With the Bets regime on death sentence, how far will its retribution go reports Elisa Marcante of SBC Noticias Brazil The future of online gambling in Brazil…

Elisa Marcante A proposal by deputy Ricardo Abrão to make Bets operators reimburse customer losses has drawn instant criticism from Brazilian legal experts. With the Bets regime on death sentence, how far will its retribution go reports Elisa Marcante of SBC Noticias Brazil The future of online gambling in Brazil remains to be settled in the halls of Congress, but one lawmaker is seeking to open a new front of dispute… Compounding the headaches of Brazilian licences, Federal deputy Ricardo Abrão (PSDB-RJ) is questioning whether operators should repay money lost by customers under the Bets Law regime. Abrão has made his case via Bill (PL) No. 5,502/2026, submitted to the Chamber of Deputies. His bill takes the title of “Full Restitution and Compensation for Bettors Law.” As reported by SBC Notícias Brasil, the proposal was referred on 12 November to the Consumer Protection Committee (CDC) and the Constitution, Justice and Citizenship Committee (CCJC) for further examination. Restitution is Abrão’s central objective. The deputy seeks to make operators responsible for repaying money lost accounted for by the Bets regime, with obligations extending to unpaid winnings or improperly withheld customer funds. Abrão believes that he has put forward a calculation to compensate consumers net losses from online gambling platforms licensed under the suspended Bets regime. Retribution would see Bets licences provide customers with “detailed transaction statements within 10 working days”. The proposal lists 10 circumstances requiring reimbursement, including total net losses recorded in customer accounts, unreturned balances, unpaid winnings, cancelled bets and unauthorised transactions. Abrão seeks support from political blocs in Congress, in which he justified his proposal as fair retribution on gambling licences that had participated in the “unchecked expansion of a market that has harmed vulnerable Brazilians, making repayment of customers’ losses necessary.” As decided by Justice Luiz Fux, the Supreme Federal Court (STF) has suspended lower-court proceedings challenging the betting ban introduced by President Lula on 25 September 2026. The Supreme Court will rule on the constitutionality of Lula’s online gambling ban. Congress must separately decide whether to convert Lula ban from a presidential order into a federal law. Abrão argued that the President’s provisional measure (No. 1,394/2026) had made consumer refunds an applicable measure. “The urgency and relevance of this proposal are grounded in the situation following the suspension of operations,” he stated in the bill’s submission. The deputy argued that operators and their controlling shareholders should foot the bill of a failed regime, with no cost to taxpayers. Lawyers wrath Udo Seckelmann The inclusion of betting losses drew instant backlash from Udo Seckelmann, a lawyer and partner at Bichara e Motta Advogados, who described the proposal to SBC Notícias Brasil as “a genuine legal aberration”. “In practice, it seeks to force operators to return money lost by bettors through lawfully placed bets, as though the activity did not, by its very nature, involve risks and the possibility of losses,” Seckelmann told SBC Notícias Brasil. “Holding companies accountable for fraud, operational failures or breaches of contract is one thing; turning legitimate losses into an obligation to reimburse is something entirely different. The proposal subverts the legal rationale underpinning betting, undermines legal certainty and disregards the inherently uncertain nature of betting contracts.” Assessing the financial and operational consequences of the proposal, Seckelmann warned that its effects could be “potentially devastating”. “Financially, operators could be required to reimburse billions of reais in losses accumulated by bettors, creating an unpredictable and potentially unpayable liability,” he said. “Operationally, the obligation to reconstruct individual transaction histories for millions of users within an extremely short time frame is practically impossible to fulfil.” Constitutional challenges expected Seckelmann told SBC Notícias Brasil that the proposal would significantly increase the exposure of companies and their directors on financial liability, undermining the sector’s viability. Asked whether the bill could advance through Congress and secure approval, he said: “Politically, the bill could find support given the current climate of pressure against the betting sector. However, its approval should face significant constitutional obstacles, particularly given potential violations of legal certainty, proportionality, freedom of enterprise and the protection of validly completed legal acts. Seckelmann warned: “Consumer protection cannot serve as justification for creating arbitrary financial obligations or disregarding the nature of lawfully concluded contracts. If approved in its current form, the bill will certainly be challenged in court.”